Gen Z blamed for decline in customer service – but is the retail industry failing them?

Issues like staff shortages, low wages, and growing competition from online shopping are plaguing the retail industry

In her column, Picton-James pointed out that customer satisfaction in physical stores seems to be getting worse, and she thinks it might be because Gen Z is now a big part of the workforce. 

She talked about her own bad experiences with young staff, mentioning things like eye rolls and a lack of interest in helping customers. 

When she went to Clarks to buy her daughter’s first pair of school shoes, she said the staff was so unhelpful that she gave up and decided to buy the shoes online instead.

“They're the online generation,” Picton-James said, suggesting that growing up in the digital age might have left many Gen Z workers struggling with face-to-face communication. 

“Their communication skills seem to be lacking.”

But is this criticism fair? Some people would argue that we might be judging Gen Z too harshly. 

Picton-James herself admitted that not all young workers fit this description, but her comments add to a growing idea that Gen Z isn't as strong in social skills as older generations.

It's also important to think about the challenges Gen Z faces in the retail world today. 

Many retail jobs are low-paid, with long hours and little appreciation, which could make it harder for young people to stay motivated. 

Is it really a surprise that customer service might suffer in these conditions?

On the other hand, Picton-James did praise Gen Z for setting better work-life boundaries, especially in office jobs. 

“I know that they don’t take calls after business hours, and they’re really pushing back on a lot of office culture," she said, calling it a positive change. 

However, this attitude might clash with what customers expect in retail settings, where staff are often expected to be more attentive.

The journalist also pointed to data showing that “80% of customers are abandoning their trips and buying online because of how bad the experience they are getting in stores is these days.” 

But this might not be just a generational issue. 

The retail industry has been struggling with staff shortages, low wages, and growing competition from online shopping - all of which affect how stores operate.

So, is Gen Z really to blame for the decline in customer service, or are we being too hard on a generation trying to navigate a difficult work environment?

READ MORE: